Skip to main content
December 9, 2021
Question

1Password Mini Not Copying Shown Password

  • December 9, 2021
  • 25 replies
  • 350 views

For a while I thought I was loosing my mind, but I just caught 1Password Mini not copying the generated password it shows.

For example, I just clicked on the 1Password Mini icon (Mac, running Monterey 12.0.1 and 1Password 7.9.1) and then the "Generate Password" button. I use "Memorable Passwords" with periods separating the words. The Password Generator offers a password such as cadenza.PARALLAX.primer, but when I click the "Copy and Save" button and then go paste the password elsewhere, it pastes something completely different: key.neckband.ARID. This is reproducible.

I just had my wife try and the first time she tried, 1Password Mini displayed and pasted the same thing. Second/third attempts did not display and paste the same password as shown in 1Password Mini.

The good news is the saved passwords in the 1Password app do reflect what was actually copied/saved, vs
what was displayed at the time.

I'm including screenshots...

Thanks for having a look at this.

Kirk out

Here's 1Password Mini:

And here's what got copied to the Clipboard:


1Password Version: Not Provided
Extension Version: Not Provided
OS Version: Not Provided

25 replies

May 19, 2022

Hey @kirkvan, can you share a bit more about your use cases for wanting the password generator to be so prevalant without wanting to save those passwords as items in 1Password? For most folks we've talked to, if they generate a new password it's because they want that saved as an item to use later. I'd like to better understand the use cases so we can think through how/why/where we can improve things here with all of the relevant information.

... It seems like all keyboard shortcuts which bring up the Quick Access window should behave in the same way, no?

The big difference here is that Command+\ has always autofilled a Login without showing any UI at all if you only have one login for the current site, where the other shortcut is to show the UI in order to search for things for all sorts of purposes. Command+\ only shows the UI if it isn't sure which item to fill to help you find which one you wanted. That's the reasoning behind the two shortcuts with different behavior. Having autofill inside of apps as well as web browsers has definitely changed expectations here for some folks though as previously, because there was no autofill in apps, it would feel like Command+\ was the same as the other shortcut whenever you weren't in a browser (previous "show UI" shortcut was Shift+Command+\ in 1Password 7).

Regarding "lock on quit" ... if you had a setting like that turned on, and you activate the shortcut for Quick Access which requires you to unlock, would you then expect it to be locked every time you activate Quick Access again? Even if it's within a minute or two? With the menu bar icon running, the app is never really "quit" as John mentioned, so a lot of people think of "quit" as different things. And things like that are the big gotchas with "lock on quit" as a feature. It's been confusing for a lot of folks and in the past has ended up frustrating more than it's helped in my experience. But we are definitely keeping track of feedback like this and considering it!

May 20, 2022

Use case for Password Generator: As a Mac consultant, I often send clients sensitive information in the form of a password protected .pdf. This is a one-off thing and I call them with the password to open the .pdf. I don’t ever need to know the password again, so saving it to 1Password would only clutter my vault.

Jack_P_1P
1Password Employee
May 23, 2022

Hi @Kirkvan:

Thanks for sharing. While I can't promise anything, as Dan mentioned, we're continuing to think through how / when / where we can improve things.

Jack

May 27, 2022

In addition to my feature requests above, I would also like to suggest that the "Copy Username" and "Copy Password" shortcuts in grey text at the bottom of the Quick Access window be clickable. And am I missing the options to "Reveal" and/or "Show In Large Type" options in the QuickAccess window?

Many thanks!

Jack_P_1P
1Password Employee
June 8, 2022

Hi @Kirkvan:

Thanks for your feedback on that, I'll make sure to share it with the team.

Jack