Skip to main content
April 3, 2022
Question

Add options to change 1Password for Safari's icon

  • April 3, 2022
  • 59 replies
  • 2769 views

The icon for 1Password for Safari doesn't follow convention and clashes with the other icons on Safari.

Take a look at this screenshot using this community site as an example. The other icons on the Safari Toolbar (Noir, 1Blocker, Share) have sections that are transparent, and look pretty good against the page's theme-color. This oddity is even clearer on a new window, where the 1Password icon is noticeably darker than the others.



1Password Version: 8.7.0 (Beta)
Extension Version: 2.3.1
OS Version: macOS 12.3.1

59 replies

repoles
January 25, 2023

Oh my… the Safari extension icon is terrible. On the Mac I completely remove it from my toolbar. But it’s not possible to do the same on the iPad. My only option is to disable the extension.

steph_giles
1Password Employee
January 26, 2023

Hey @repoles,

Thank you for your feedback I will pass it on to our product team. If you had the choice, could you describe to me what you would like the icon to look like? Is it the colours you are not a fan of?

repoles
January 27, 2023

Like they say, a picture is worth a thousand words.

steph_giles
1Password Employee
January 27, 2023

@repoles, I have passed on your feedback.

Have a great weekend.

ref: PB-30542985

March 23, 2023

@steph_giles "If you had the choice, could you describe to me what you would like the icon to look like?" I can do you one better, here's the actual SVG asset we'd all like to replace the awful full-color version, it's been hiding in plain sight as a favicon on your very own support page: https://support.1password.com/img/favicon/pinned-tab-v2.svg

This SVG could be added to the extension in literal seconds by your devs, as it isn't anything new that they have to create. That said, an optimized version with slightly thinner lines couldn't hurt, @awn also did a nice mockup.

Here's another example FROM YOUR OWN support page again, showing the icon from the old v7 extension. The current icon is a regressive change and sticks out like a sore thumb

It sticks out in a bad way amongst the other extensions I use

Edit:
Y'know what, let me continue to remove ambiguity for you. Here's a literal example of what it should look like on a stock Mac OS install:

Light

Dark

And for the full experience, custom accent colors

steph_giles
1Password Employee
March 29, 2023

Thank you so much @aiyah, I appreciate this level of detail.

I have added all of this information to a request for our product team to take into consideration.

ref: PB32030307

kelchm
April 1, 2023

I'd really love to see this addressed. This icon is a really disappointing regression compared to the Safari extension for 1Password 7.

1Password Employee
April 1, 2023

Hi @kelchm , thanks for sharing your thoughts. I've passed your feedback along to our Product team.

PB32120265

jmanes
May 30, 2023

I know this is the world's tiniest complaint but I agree with the folks here. Just from a UI fit-and-finish perspective an icon update for the Safari extension could go a long way here.

1P_Dave
1Password Employee
May 30, 2023

@jmanes

Thank you for the feedback, I've passed it along to the team. 🙂

-Dave

ref: dev/core/core#9400
ref: PB-33370668