Skip to main content
gussic
Aug 13, 2021 1:33 AM UTC
Question

Cross platform design philosophy

@1P_Ben @MrRooni @roustem

I understand a part for you deciding to go for Electron on the front end was so that the Apps could all look and feel as close as possible to each other across the various different platforms. Can I ask, seriously, who actually asked for this?

I've done a quick and dirty survey of my non technically bless friends - not a single one of them expects or wants Apps to behave the same way across all platforms. All of them expect, and are happy to accept that each platform will make Apps looks and behave differently.

Shouldn't the focus being on using the best available to technologies and frameworks to make each App feel, look and function the best for its respect platform, even if that means it isn't exactly consistent across each?

I'm just struggling to understand this design decision, and it makes me sad because it really feels like an absolute betrayal for one of the key things you used to stand for, having the best native Mac Apps possible. Using Electron is completely at odds with having the best native Mac App possible, because there are other, better frameworks out there.


1Password Version: Not Provided
Extension Version: Not Provided
OS Version: Not Provided

35 replies

Aug 13, 2021 2:56 PM UTC

I'm quite happy to get the features from the Apple versions over to my platforms.

I hear this, and am all for it.

Unfortunately for those of us using the preview on Mac for the moment, it's less "other platforms getting the features that were Apple-native" and more "stripping the Mac-native version to match the others."

Aug 13, 2021 3:13 PM UTC

Unfortunately for those of us using the preview on Mac for the moment, it's less "other platforms getting the features that were Apple-native" and more "stripping the Mac-native version to match the others."

I don't know how you came to this impression, but that is NOT what is happening. You're looking at an early preview that doesn't have all the features yet, but my understanding is that there will be feature parity with previous versions and then some.

You wouldn't judge a newborn by its cooking abilities, would you.

Aug 13, 2021 3:19 PM UTC

You wouldn't judge a newborn by its cooking abilities, would you.
Well, if the newborn had no eyes and hands, then I would know that life will be hard for it. This is the state of 1Password8 on the Mac.

Aug 13, 2021 3:25 PM UTC

Don't be ridiculous.

Aug 13, 2021 3:45 PM UTC

@cryptochrome

I respectfully disagree on the RAM point. Several major vendors, Apple included, still sell laptops and desktops that only have 8GB of RAM, the former of which can’t be upgraded. Furthermore, there’s quite a lot of people who are still using old laptops with only 8GB of soldered RAM because those machines still meet those users’ requirements, making spending on upgrades a dicey value proposition (especially with how processing power has plateaued in the past decade).

Personally, yes, I won't buy anything with less than 16GB, and have preference for a 32GB+. But I’m a software engineer and tech enthusiast, and as such I’m in a very tiny bubble. The average individual isn’t so well off in terms of hardware, and because of that I do what I can to make sure the software I work on is finely crafted and doesn’t require more resources than it absolutely has to, because a few hundred megs here and a few hundred megs there pile up fast.

Aug 13, 2021 3:50 PM UTC

I am pretty sure 1P performs exceptionally well on a modern OS with just 8 gig of RAM installed. Especially on macOS, where we have things like memory compression.

It's a mute argument. The 1P folks have demonstrated in another thread how Electrum based 1P only uses 75 MB of main memory and another 25 MB for the Electrum renderer. On an installation with four accounts and thousands of objects.

Aug 13, 2021 4:04 PM UTC

Several users have posted examples of 1PW8 using well in excess of 250MB. I hope AgileBits can get that cleaned up, but based on the track records of other apps that made the switch to Electron I’m not optimistic. For those other apps, usage dropped by 10-15% once all the optimizations had been implemented, and no further attempts at reducing consumption were made by the developers.

And of course 1PW8 is going to run fine on its own, where the real issue comes in is when several things are running… especially when many of things are also electron (hard to avoid these days). All it takes is a typical number of browser tabs and 2-3 electron/electron-like apps (slack, spotify, 1PW, evernote for example seems like a plausible combination) and the machine is going to have to start hitting the pagefile (even with memory compression) and performance will take a very noticeable hit.

I don’t intend to continue arguing, but resource consumption is a huge problem that’s going mostly unaddressed by the biggest names in software.

Aug 13, 2021 4:13 PM UTC

Well if your computer can't keep up with modern apps anymore, maybe it's time for an upgrade. You can't expect your old machines to perform well forever.

That being said, one user having 250 MB and another 75 MB clearly shows that this is not yet optimized. But if it can go down to 75 MB already, then I don't know how that can be a concern.

You are all judging an early alpha release and make assumptions based on that. You should at least give 1P the chance to deliver a final product before spamming the forums with manufactured outrage (that goes to everyone, not you in particular). Some here act as if 1P8 means it's the end of the world.

Aug 13, 2021 4:23 PM UTC

I installed 1P8 on my M1 iMac (16GB RAM) and used it with 1P7 at the same time. The difference is night and day. 1P7 uses around 130MB RAM on my system while the Electron app uses 250MB.
As far as the UI concerns, it definitely has nothing to do with a Mac app. It is too empty, scrolling feels unnatural to a Mac (no bouncing when reaching the top or bottom). I also prefer the categories on the side and not as a filter on top. All in all I prefer 1P7. It feels right on my Mac. I also do not like the way 1P8 preferences pop up. You also get only an x on the top right and no option to minimize the window, like on 1P7. It's disappointing. The only thing I liked is the search box, which works really well. Apart from that the Mac version is a big step backwards and a regression from 1P7 in all possible ways that matter to a user. For the business decision makers this is of course a great step, since they are saving lots amounts of money, by developing once for all platforms. The investors will definitely be happy.

Aug 13, 2021 4:25 PM UTC

Like I said, I hope AgileBits can clean it up. But so frequently these days, “it’s an alpha, it’ll get fixed!” never actually comes to pass for half or more of the problems users report, and those problems live on in production for years if they ever get addressed. I’ve seen it happen time and time again across several different types of software.