Disable Using Native Controls

Some recent update or configuration that was pushed to default set my Safari to use the native Mac passwords form field controls for 1Password. I want to disable this.

This option is disabled, and believe that if it is enabled. I’ll get the experience I want back.

What do I need to do, to get this option back ?

Why do i want this? 

First: the native controls asks me for touch-id to fill in my username, and my password, and my OTP. That’s three taps for one login. Even if the 1Password extension is unlocked, which it always is because i use it to open the page. I don’t know if this is a Mac Passwords thing or a 1Password MacOS integration thing, either way, it’s an incredibly terrible experience. 

Second: The native controls only ever show the first entry. I have to manually navigate to “show more” when I have multiple accounts I could use. Again, this is annoying. I used to see every (or most) option right on the form field selection. 1-click is better than 3.

Anyone able to help me get back to a 1Password native experience?

-B