Feedback: Universal Sign-In Functionality
I've only just now encountered this Universal Sign-in prompt for the first time on my Mac. I turned it off immediately, and wanted to chime in my feedback about why. Admittedly my thoughts are a repeat of criticisms plenty of others have already expressed in older topics (side note: I actually tried to put this as a reply to one recent-ish topic, but the site simply ate my reply instead of posting it, even while adding the topic itself to my follow list as if I had successfully replied). However, the fact that I can find such older topics (even Beta topics from nearly a year ago) all expressing my same criticisms, and this functionality is nonetheless now rolling out to everyone with its behavior seemingly mostly unchanged despite that feedback, well.. that doesn't bode well for being listened to.
So: I do NOT like any sort of automatic visual intrusion into the browser's UI. No pop-ups, period, and in particular ones that I didn't deliberately invoke! And most *especially* I hate animated stuff. The slide in/slide out is pure distraction, and slows everything down. Everything about the USI prompt is just awful in that regard. In fact I not only have all browser animations disabled via browser settings, but in Windows/macOS/iOS all I use the Accessibility options to disable all OS-level animations too ("Reduce Motion" as Apple calls it). 1P really ought to recognize and honor such OS-level Accessibility settings, but that's a separate topic.
However, and more to the point for why I wanted to leave feedback, I currently have "Show autofill suggestions when a field is selected" turned OFF in 1P in the Browser--that's for the old sign in functionality obviously. My point being I already have automatic pop-ups from the extension turned off! I don't want 1P preemptively popping anything up at all, even when I select a field. I use the autofill hotkey, or I click the 1P icon at the end of the text field or in the browser's toolbar in order to bring up login suggestions--all of which are deliberate, user-invoked actions. Don’t try to guess what I'm doing, don't “suggest” ahead of time; I'll tell the app what I want it to do--or if I want it to do anything at all.
Universal Sign-In ignores the fact that I have such suggestions turned off already, so it’s now yet another, secondary “suggestion” pop-up, completely unwanted and unasked for. Worse, it seems to pop up directly on page load, not even waiting for me to select a field (or perhaps the webpage was auto-selecting the field, something I find very annoying in itself but that part isn't 1P's fault).
I think the overall concept of Universal Sign-in itself is a nice idea, but as others have already said, the UI implementation is simply bad. If there were a way to use USI without the automatic pop-ups at all (via the autofill hotkey or a new hotkey, or by manually clicking the 1P icon at the end of text field or in browser toolbar--all just like the old autofill system already works), I’d consider turning it back on.
As long as the preemptive, automatic pop-ups are the only way to use USI, it will remain permanently off. And if at some point in the future USI becomes the only autofill functionality in use and it still works the way it does right now, that will be the day I uninstall 1P in the Browser. Yes, I hate these sorts of pop-up intrusions that much.
