Passkeys and multiple accounts for a site is broken

@Joy_1P

Yep, I'm aware that the issue with tying passkeys to the browser lies with Google, and my comment was in regards to that. But as you said (wrote?), we can only hope that Google does something about it in the future. For what it's worth, I've sent feedback to Google according to the instructions in the link you provided. Those instructions though, are for feedback regarding Chrome, and the passkey issue is system wide. But getting in touch with Google isn't the easiest, so I guess we'll have to make do with what we got and hopefully the feedback will find its way to the right department.

I've made a recording and sent to the email address according to your instructions. In the email I also included step by step information to clarify what's happening in the recording. The Support ID is: [#APA-73863-462]

@Backspaze

Yep, I'm aware that the issue with tying passkeys to the browser lies with Google, and my comment was in regards to that. But as you said (wrote?), we can only hope that Google does something about it in the future. For what it's worth, I've sent feedback to Google according to the instructions in the link you provided. Those instructions though, are for feedback regarding Chrome, and the passkey issue is system wide. But getting in touch with Google isn't the easiest, so I guess we'll have to make do with what we got and hopefully the feedback will find its way to the right department.

Gotcha! I misunderstood and had wanted to clarify. I do find that it is hard to get in touch with Google, but their developers do seem to be active on https://bugs.chromium.org. If you take a look, you'll find some reports of passkey-related bugs on there. So it does seem like they're working hard from their end too. It might be worth making a report to see if you get a response.

I've made a recording and sent to the email address according to your instructions. In the email I also included step by step information to clarify what's happening in the recording. The Support ID is: [#APA-73863-462]

Thanks for sending us the recording! I do see that one of our support specialists have responded. Let's continue the conversation from there.

ref: APA-73863-462

I can confirm this behavior for Microsoft as well (login.live.com). If I put the email address in first, or click "open and fill" option in 1Password it still will just sign me in with the first account I created.

I'm on Windows 11 Pro (22H2, 22621.1848), Chrome 114.0.5735.199, and 1Password in the browser, Beta 2.13.1. I have multiple logins with google.com and have passkeys associated with all the google.com logins. I am seeing the same issue with loging in -- I get stuck in an "authentication" loop where it repeatedly tries one of my accounts (I believe it is the last passkey saved), independent of which account I select on google.com. It appears to be identical to the one reported by @Backspaze. Please let me know if I can help with replicating or debugging this issue.

I'm having this issue on https://www.passkeys.io/.

I have two accounts (differing email addresses) and it is impossible for me to sign into the account with the alternative email address. It auto signs in with the first passkey. Definitely not right!

Seeing the same thing on github.com

Same on github.com too, I can provide any additional info by request (because not sure, what do you need in this case)

Thanks folks. The team is working with how to selecting a specific passkey out of multiple passkeys for any give site. I hope we'll be able to address this soon.

Same here. Look at github.com as another UC to check.

Cross posting this post from one of the developers.

https://1password.community/discussion/comment/691745/#Comment_691745