Two Apple ID - Only one available in AutoFill

I have two Apple IDs, one for Media and Purchases, one for everything else. For as long as I have been using 1P (A long time) when I am prompted to autofill an Apple ID, only one of those passwords (The everything else one) is shown in the list, the other acts like it doesn’t exist. If I open the 1P program I see it. It’s only an issue in the autofill popups.