Skip to main content
Oct 10, 2026 2:49 PM UTC
Question

Handling and merging multiple passkeys

I have many items related to “amazon.com”. I have personal Amazon accounts. I have work accounts. I have multiple AWS accounts. My personal Amazon account has a passkey on it for my Mac.

I needed to log into my personal Amazon account on my phone. This encouraged me to create a new passkey.

1Password did not offer my personal account as an option to update. It only offered one of my AWS accounts. So I had to select “create new item.”

Now I have two items for my personal Amazon account, one with a Mac passkey and one with a phone passkey. How can I merge these? This article on merging with passkeys suggests copying items from the non-passkey item to the passkey item, but both of these are passkey items. Also, how do I distinguish between these passkeys? Is creation date the only data I have?

(Brief passkey rant; fee free to ignore: Passkeys continue to be my bane. I once again regret allowing one to be created, and the answer to this question is probably “delete it and stop making passkeys.” They work great for the simplest possible case, and fall apart completely if anything is the least bit unusual, and things are always unusual. I’m a long-time infosec person. I know why they were built. I was a huge fan of the spec when it first came out. Everything about the actual deployment has been a nightmare.)

1 reply

Trevor_1P
1Password Employee
1Password Employee
Oct 19, 2026 7:58 PM UTC

Hi ​@rnapier,

If you have multiple passkeys for the same account, the best option would be to save them in separate items. With that said, if you have a passkey saved in your existing Amazon Login item, you should be able to use it on any device/browser that you use 1Password on. To confirm, did you not see the passkey offered when signing in to your Amazon account on your phone? If not, could you confirm if the URL saved in your new item is different than the one saved in your original item?