Skip to main content
benmattison
Oct 12, 2026 6:33 PM UTC

Selecting from multiple passkeys on the same website

I have a frequently used website where I sign in with two different passkeys. Before universal sign-in, both popped up and I could select either. Now, even though I have universal sign-in turned off, they come up in the universal sign-in interface and only one of them pops up (not sure what determines which) and I have to click on “Other Logins” to get to the second one. 

Hoping the new interface will eventually accomodate two logins or, or that it could just revert to the old interface when you turn universal sign-in off. 

3 replies

1P_Dave
1Password Employee
1Password Employee
Oct 13, 2026 9:05 PM UTC

Hello ​@benmattison! 👋

Thank you for the question. The centre prompt is now the default for passkeys, even when the new sign-in experience is disabled for other login types, such as password autofill. We made this change to focus development resources on a single prompt and because the new prompt supports important passkey features like user verification:

1Password will suggest your most frequently used item by default. To select another passkey, press the down arrow on your keyboard, then press Enter to sign in.

Does using the keyboard to select the second passkey help? If not, could you tell me a little more about what you’d like to see added to the prompt?

-Dave

benmattison
Oct 13, 2026 10:03 PM UTC

​@1P_Dave Thanks for the response. I’d just like to be able to select either login with the same number of clicks, but it doesn’t sound like that is going to be an option. On this particular site, I use two different passkeys more or less equally, so “most frequently used” keeps switching back and forth, which makes it hard to maintain some muscle memory. 

More generally, it really comes down to the fact that I preferred the old design. 

This is off-topic, but having to authenticate with TouchID every time on some sites is changing the calculation about whether passkeys are actually more convenient. 

 

1P_Dave
1Password Employee
1Password Employee
Oct 20, 2026 3:55 PM UTC

​@benmattison 

Thank you for the feedback about selecting passkeys on websites where you may have multiple passkeys available, I’ve shared it with our team internally. 

Regarding user verification with Touch ID or another method, this is enforced by the individual website itself and 1Password merely honours the request. You can read more here.

-Dave