Skip to main content
November 9, 2021
Question

Trouble changing passwords

  • November 9, 2021
  • 32 replies
  • 2558 views

I know you are trying to make 1P better and help with changing passwords. Yet your software needs improvement. I am continually running into situations where 1P is "trying too hard", and I get into a situation where the password is messed up and I don't know what it is. So I have to do a password reset.

Because of long-standing issues in this area, I adopted the practice of saving existing passwords in a text editor and putting new ones there. I cannot tell you how many times I have to resort to those extra steps to save the day, as the automated features of 1P just fail.

The net result is all the "helpfulness" results in unnecessary password reset requests with websites.

Could you please simplify this and either get all the unwanted helpfulness out of the way or make it just work?


1Password Version: 7.9.1
Extension Version: 2.1.4
OS Version: 10.15.7

32 replies

December 14, 2021

These are some great suggestions Former Member !
Thanks for taking the time to share your thoughts and feedback on this. I will forward it to the team.

jasimon9Author
December 14, 2021

Thank you to Tertius3 for chiming in.

I have used 1P since 2009. The change password function worked pretty well for most of that time. However, during the last year it has become extremely difficult. Sometimes it works, but at least half the time it results in a large amount of rework, including additional password resets with websites.

It is a fact that when you create a new password, it you don't save it temporarily somewhere, you are asking for a good chance of quite a bit of additional rework. The fact that I have a listing of passwords, including the current one and the new one, available in a separate text editor has saved me countless episodes of frustration.

The automated support from 1P should just work. It doesn't.

Here are things that need to be improved:
- the password history function. Used to be great. Now it is useless.
- the confusing UI where you get multiple popups, some covering others, and you never know whether to click Save, or something else. The fact that Kevin.li gives a workaround demonstrates somewhat the issues.

Hope this helps.

December 15, 2021

@jasimon9:

Thank you as well for the feedback!

the password history function. Used to be great. Now it is useless.

I am curious about this, do you mind elaborating? How is it useless now, and how was it great before?

jasimon9Author
December 15, 2021

There used to be a password history feature. It is no longer there.

December 16, 2021

@jasimon9:

It's here:

See also our previous discussion https://1password.community/discussion/124996/password-change-history-is-hidden for all the details :+1:

jasimon9Author
December 18, 2021

Many times there is no such choice. Does that mean there is no history present?

December 19, 2021

It probably means there's no history to show for that particular item. If you're on a website and trying to change a password but failed to save it, the new password won't be stored in the item's history, but rather in the generator's history:

  1. Click the 1Password extension icon in your browser's toolbar to open it.
  2. Click the Key button on the top right area to reach the generator.
  3. Click the "Generator History" button at the bottom to view and recover any lost new passwords that were used in websites but weren't saved.
jasimon9Author
December 19, 2021

I see the generator history in the 1P extension in Chrome. That could be useful in these edge cases!

However, I have recently switched to Safari, and trying to make a go of that. I don't see the "Key" button or another way to access the generator in the Safari version.

December 20, 2021

Hey @jasimon9 ,

Safari is indeed different. When you use a new generated password on a website, it is automatically saved as a new "Password" item in your 1Password app (an item with a grey key icon instead of a website's icon/logo). When you update that new password in the relevant login item, that password item will disappear automatically as to not clutter your 1Password, but if you failed to save/update the new password, then you can find it in the "Passwords" category of your 1Password app.

jasimon9Author
December 20, 2021

Thanks for the explanation.