Forum Discussion
Two banking logins and 2FA
Thank you! That worked.
I've also stumbled on this, I use Google Docs extensively and found this annoying. The workaround does work, but none the less I think 1Password should change its shortcut.
Reading through this thread, I see this as user-hostile behaviour, wrapped in very gentle words. It's entirely not OK to re-steal the shortcut after users have asserted control over it. I find it so irritating that I'm close to actively researching alternatives, even with all of the hassle of a switch.
steph_giles1Password Team
Hey @Mike123456,
I can definitely understand your frustration and you're right, this is not how it is supposed to work I was just trying to gain a little more insight to see if we could figure out why this may be happening. If it resets again can you grab the following details and send them over to the team so we can further investigate:
Please attach the reports to an email message addressed to support+forum@1password.com with a link to this thread.
I'm sorry for the disruption @llamallama, I have added your feedback to the internal issue.
ref: dev/core/core#9365
Adding a +1 to this, I was frustrated that I already changed the setting in the 1password app, AND had the extension using the app. However, I still had to change the extension-specific keyboard shortcuts to remove this. Please don't take over established content-editing shortcuts.
No, I don't do anything like that. I'm fairly certain it's specific to your extension, I don't have this issue with other extensions. I frequently have weeks of uptime, so it's not like I'm resetting things frequently. I do restart to apply browser updates when available, but that does not seem to coincide with the extension resetting. I do not replace the shortcut with something else, but I should not need to. The shortcut is not a feature I use, and so if I leave it blank it should not get reset and should continue to respect my choice. Maybe instead of blaming the user and customer, which is how I take your questions, try fixing the extension. Or at least pick a shortcut that doesn't conflict with a very popular tool.
- steph_giles
Hey @Mike123456,
I'm sorry for the trouble, I'd be interested to hear more about the issue you are seeing. Do you clear your browser history frequently or have it set to after a period of time?
This is still a problem. It's super irritating, and is making me consider dropping 1Password for an alternative. For why it come back in the browser, it looks like either when there is a browser or extension update, it resets the keyboard shortcut. It's super shortsighted of 1Password developers to continue to use a keyboard shortcut that is widely used in a bigger application (sorry, but it is). It wouldn't bother me if it was a 1 time "fix" and didn't get reset, but every couple weeks it seems like it messes up and I have to go in and remove the shortcut. Heck, I'd even take a way to just disable keyboard shortcuts in the extension, as long as that setting didn't get reset.
- steph_giles
Thanks for your feedback @bobbychaz, I have passed it on to the team.
ref: dev/core/core#8796
+1 to change the default and save us a step. thanks!
@saro I'm sorry that you've had to disable the 1Password extension in Chrome. I'll test things out on on my end to see if I can reproduce the behavior after Chrome updates. As a note, it might be a while before I can share my test results. I am running the latest version of Chrome at this time.
With the 1Password extension in Chrome off, I recommend using Universal Autofill from the 1Password desktop app to fill your logins: https://support.1password.com/mac-universal-autofill/
I hope that can help for now. Let us know if you have any other questions.
