Hi @"paul.m_1p",
First, thanks for passing along my feedback to the team!
So, yes, I do have the desktop app installed and, yes, I grant you that about there is no popup when initiating authentication from a login field. :)
Use-case-wise, however, I still prefer the "Do Nothing" option on the extension because I often want to re-unlock without the need to immediately navigate to a new page, tab, etc.; that is, I am staying put where I am for the moment but just want 1Password unlocked.
Most importantly, however, the reason I'm not the biggest fan of authenticating via a login field is that logins are so inconsistent from site to site; some have icons in the fields that interfere with accurately clicking on the 1Password icon; there are even some sites I visit where 1Password does not show the icon and I have to right-click in the field and use the menu option instead.
But that Browser extension? It is reliably and consistently there, in the same spot, at the top of my Browser window, always! It's like I can close my eyes and still mouse over and click on the Browser extension, lol! :D
Once again, thanks for listening and passing along the info to your team. Unlike what I was using before 1Password, it's very refreshing to interact with you guys because you actually listen to and value customer feedback.