VS Code remote ssh triggering wrong ssh key

When trying to connect to a machine using the Remote SSH extension, 1Password prompts me to authorize the SSH key, but it's always the wrong key.

Connecting via PowerShell using the same config works without any problem, so I'm not sure if it's 1Passwords fault.

OS: Windows 11
1Password version: 8.12.10
VS Code version: 1.116.0
Remote - SSH version: 0.122.0