autofill vs open and fill

Ohhhhhhhhh. "It's acting like I'm already sitting at the site I've chosen." That led me to the answer:

Those Autofill-only entries have blank "website" entries. The label "website" has been entered - it's not the faint "website" that's acting as a prompt to enter some actual label, it's a darkened "website" that has been entered, but there isn't an actual website to go to entered.

All I needed to do is click the red remove icon for each of those blank entries and now it's working.

It's both odd and understandable that 1Password would prefer the blank entry over the actual entry. Understandable because there IS an actual entry even though it's blank. Odd because what use is a 1Pwd entry that is not an actual website?

I'm good. Sorry to bug ya!