Forum Discussion

Oddycm's avatar
Oddycm
Occasional Contributor
2 years ago

How to Test Recovery Code?

Hello,

Would it be possible to have a feature where users can test their Recovery Code after generating them. I am envisioning a separate interface where the user inputs the code and is told if it is correct or not.

I understand after generating the code a user is prompted to enter the code before finishing the process. However, since this code is the only secret that can be written down on paper it would be great to be able to test if it works.

In comparison, there exists Cryptocurrency hardware wallets that allow users to test their Seed Phrase - Since this is the most important code in the context of Cryptocurrency wallets it allows users to be confident they have the correct code and can always restore access.

Regards,
Oddycm

1Password Version: Not Provided
Extension Version: Not Provided
OS Version: Not Provided
Browser: Not Provided

passkeys

6 Replies

Sort By
  • ag_andrew's avatar
    ag_andrew
    Icon for 1Password Team rank1Password Team
    9 months ago

    Hey nicos18, this isn't something we've been able to look at yet, but I still think it's a cool idea. I'll raise it with the team 💙

  • nicos18's avatar
    nicos18
    Frequent Contributor
    9 months ago

    I'll chime in this discussion about the testing of the recovery code to see if it's working.

    I created the recovery code back in April when the feature was not officially announced, but the 1password.com website already gave the option to create a recovery code.

    Because I'd like to be sure if my code it's working, such a feature would be useful.

  • ag_andrew's avatar
    ag_andrew
    Icon for 1Password Team rank1Password Team
    2 years ago

    Oddycm I'll chime in here to mention that we've just released Beta versions of 1Password for Desktop and Mobile that include the ability to manage recovery codes in the apps. Although we don't currently have an in-app way of testing a recovery code, I think it's a cool idea.

  • JonM1PW's avatar
    JonM1PW
    Icon for 1Password Team rank1Password Team
    2 years ago

    Hey Oddycm,

    Thanks for your reply and for the additional context. That's great feedback!

    I've shared your comments with our Product team to be considered for a future improvement. I'm unable to say if, or when, this functionality will be made available, but our team is aware of your interest.

    Let me know if you've got any other thoughts. The team always looking for ways to improve 1Password and feedback like this goes a long way to ensuring 1Password is meeting customers where their needs are.

    Thanks again for helping test the passkey unlock beta. I'm here if you've got any further questions or concerns.  

    -Jon

    ref: 38956956

  • Oddycm's avatar
    Oddycm
    Occasional Contributor
    2 years ago

    I think my biggest concern is the interface does not have any feedback on the state of the current generated recovery key.

    Below we can see a interface to generate it, but it does not indicate if one has already been generated or and identifiers related to the generated key.

    Of course, we do not want the actual recovery key to be printed. However, perhaps having an identifier related to the key can be be printed along with the date it was generated on would be better?

  • 1P_Dave's avatar
    1P_Dave
    Icon for Moderator rankModerator
    2 years ago

    Hello Oddycm! 👋

    Thank you for helping us test passkey unlock in our public beta! As you mentioned, you are required to enter your recovery code as part of the recovery code creation process in order to confirm that the recovery code is correct:

    You're also give the opportunity to save a file called 1Password recovery code.txt which contains your recovery code.

    That being said, I'm happy to pass along your request to the team. Just so that I can better understand: are you worried that someone might change your copy of the recovery code? Is your goal to be able to confirm your recovery code from time to time? And, if you're concerned about the integrity of your recovery code, why not just generate a new recovery code? Once I know more I'll be able to file a feature request on your behalf. 🙂

    -Dave