Feedback: Universal sign-in, a new Autofill Experience

The search on “new experience” doesn’t work at all. I have multiple sites where I have dozens of accounts to log on (M365 being one). I have passkeys for some sites, password for many more. 

Currently my options are: 
1) Use the “new experience”. But search doesn’t work. It matches the beginning of the account name (and with M365 accounts the relevant part is in the middle) or does something else crazy. Useless. 
2) Turn off the “new experience”. Search works, but due to some brain fart the developers have decided to disable focus to login field at the same time. I get passkey popups constantly so a simple login turns into a nightmare closing popups and clicking the field before I can type anything. 
3) turn off offering passkeys. Now I get autofocus to the right field, I have a search that works, but … I do have passkeys. How do I use them now? 

I’m not against new features or new versions even though I dislike the new look quite a lot. I’m against forgetting everything you’ve learned over the years and building a new system, killing the old way of doing this. This is now the 3rd password manager I’m on, and the 3rd that did exactly the same thing: perfectly working system that’s easy to use without having to mess around with mouse constantly, then they come up with a ‘new experience’ that is prettier but absolutely useless. 

Please fix this. I can live with the current system if I can just turn on back the autofocus to the login/password field rather than it being hijacked by the passkey prompt. Even better would be properly working filter function to the “new experience”. Even if I don’t like the look it’s more important it works, and I doubt I can convince you to drop that look anymore. 

What’s wrong with the search is: You have account “admin@peruna.onmicrosoft.com”. I need to be able to find that when I start typing ‘per’. If I come up with 50 others that contain ‘per’ I can keep typing ‘perun’ and only get those that match it. Exactly as it has worked so far. It’s all I need. I don’t mind if the passkeys and passwords are all in that same mix, that’s probably better. What I don’t want is having to reach for my mouse every 2 minutes just to close popups or to find a search function that works. 

I’m afraid I’ll have to disable it too.
Login experience has been pretty bad since the introduction of the universal sign-in, unless I am doing something wrong.

I am on macOS and I use Edge.

1. The new login is not near the field I need to fill in. That means I’ll have to go back and forth with the mouse
2. Often the old 1Password dialog on the right also appears
3. Most importantly, the new universal login keeps appearing at the top of the screen on some websites even though there is nothing to login into. It’s incredibly annoying.

I’ll disable it for now.

I think I like Universal Sign-In but it is activating on every page on the website that I help run because we have an email address field in the footer for subscribing to our newsletter. It would be great if it could figure out that that is not actually a sign-in but barring that, how about an option to selectively disable it, perhaps in the “Options” area?

Also, I would vote no on the animation in the popup, which is distracting. 

Recently, 1Password started showing two pill-style popups on websites I am about to log in to, along with a workflow that seems to do nothing. See the attached screenshot.

The first pill shows the name of the website I am on with a suggestion to “Sign in”. Clicking it makes 1Password attempt to log in, but then it displays the second pill, “Go to the sign in page to continue”. Then it stays there, doing nothing.

But what’s the purpose? When users are not logged in, they can navigate directly to the sign-in page. Are there click savings I'm missing? Maybe it is a way to have a unified, clearly marked pill that takes users to the login page?

I was only going to comment once, but then this morning I’m being prompted to use the new login despite already having it disabled. 

Never, ever turn on things users have disabled. Ever.

I’m using a Macbook with Chrome browser extension. 

Before the upgrade to Universal Signin functionality I could use my passkey by simply clicking on the login prompt sent from 1Password.  Now, after upgrade, it asks me to enter my Mac password (or biometrics) in order to sign in with the passkey.  Why this change, and can I get it working the “old” way which was faster/simpler? Button click vs. entering a password. 

This isn’t working well with passkeys in Edge on Windows.  I’ve turned it off for now.  Coworkers of mine are on Mac/Chrome and don’t see the option to turn this off.

Running into the same issue in our enterprise. Passkeys no longer work and throws a “we could not fill your login information”. Once we disable the new experience in the extension settings, it works again. This is a huge inconvenience! 

Any eta on when a permanent fix will be rolled out? it is not feasible to have us instruct individual users to disable this setting.
 

I like the new feature, but it’s currently not working for me.
I have several credentials stored in my vault that share a common domain, but have different subdomains. E.g.:

• https://a.domain.com
• https://b.domain.com
• https://c.domain.com

When I click over a login field (E.g. username), 1Password already take this into account and the first suggested credential to complete the fields is the one matching the full subdomain+doman. The new autofill feature always suggest the same one, even if the subdomain doesn't match. I have this (heavily redacted) capture where I hope you can see the problem. In green, the real URL, and the right first suggestion if I click over the field. In red, the wrong suggested credential by the new autofill feature:

The autofill feature should follow the same rules for suggesting the right credential for the current site as the rest of the app features.

So since a recent update the 1Password extension on Safari shows the above style ‘Sign In’ bubble on websites.

On some, it appears despite being signed in, and in one example when I tried the ‘Sign In’ it was trying to fill in a Newsletter signup box. This might be poor design on that site, but the behaviour of this new element is getting in the way of my workflow rather than helping.

It seems to break the previous method of signing in via the sign in boxes (log in text will appear, then vanish, and above sign in bubble appears.

Is this mandatory behaviour for the Safari Extension? Is there a way to turn this feature off for now?

Alternatively, is there a keyboard shortcut to activate the ‘Sign in’ in the bubble, as at the moment I have to use mouse to do it rather than keyboard which is slowing my workflow.